Which Pizza Pie Takes the Cake?

This week, we compare pizza from three West County restaurants.

Pizza is versatile and ubiquitous, seen in many restaurants in West County. It is versatile because it can have a variety of crusts, sauces, toppings and cheeses. Some like the Chicago deep dish or St. Louis-style thin crust with provel cheese, and others swear by New York-style pizza with a thick foldable crust and real mozzarella cheese.

 17304 Chesterfield Airport Rd., Chesterfield
As a New Yorker, walking into East Coast Pizza was like walking into a pizza shop at home. The red pepper flakes on the table and the garlic powder reminded me of going to eat pizza with my dad. The crust was crisp and flavorful, but foldable. There is something about the brick they cook it on that makes this pizza special. The sauce, unfortunately, was a little bland even with the garlic powder, which was a little disappointing. The cheese, however, was phenomenal—bubbling from the oven with irresistible texture, pulling you in for another bite. There were some golden brown spots on the cheese from the cooking process, further solidifying the quality and authenticity of the mozzarella cheese. Chesterfield Patch did a full of East Coast Pizza, for those intrigued further.

The good: The crust and the cheese were unique (at least in St. Louis) and amazing in flavor and texture.
The bad:
The sauce really needed more seasoning.

 1160 Town and Country Crossing Dr., Town and Country
At Whole Foods, you can shop in different countries in the same aisle, from the sushi bar to fresh gelato to the pizza station. One of the great things about the pizza here is the choice to have a whole wheat crust. The crust had a complex and nutty layer of flavor, but I am the type to choose whole wheat bread over white bread any day. It was not particularly crispy, but decent. The sauce was had an irritating quality, making my mouth uncomfortable (it might have been too much salt or parmesan cheese). The flavor was overpowered by that unidentifiable quality in the sauce. The mozzarella cheese was golden brown and cooked well in their large ovens, but not particularly flavorful. The texture of the cheese had no stretch or elasticity, making it a little cardboard-ish.

The good: The whole wheat crust had a delicious flavor.
The bad:
 An ingredient in the sauce made it unpleasant to eat. The mozzarella cheese left something to be desired as well.

1312 Clarkson Clayton Center, Ellisville
Eating at Dewey's Pizza is a unique experience. There is a large picture window looking into the kitchen; kids and adults alike pass by and watch in amazement as cooks expertly toss pizza in the air. Dewey's has a variety of pizzas such as the delicious the Edgar Allen Poe, which has garlic, olive oil and black olives with goat, mozzarella and fontina cheeses. For comparison, I chose the Dewey's original (cheese pizza with tomato sauce). The sauce had a lot flavor and some heat, the oregano in the sauce was evident as well as other spices. The crust was unremarkable and almost a little mushy. The mozzarella cheese had decent flavor,  but didn't have the stretch and elasticity that some quality mozzarella has. The pizza stands they place on the table are a little crooked. My pizza slid off and fell behind the booth. The waitress immediately came over (she said that happens all the time—not my fault) and had the cooks make a new one at no extra charge.

The good: The sauce was excellent, and watching the cooks make the pizzas was fun.
The bad:
The crust was not crisp, and the cheese was not as flavorful as it could have been.

The winner: East Coast Pizza wins because of the superb quality, texture and flavor of both the crust and the cheese.

Charyl August 03, 2011 at 09:32 PM
You do not have any taste buds. East Coast Pizza is like food court food. Dewey's is by far the best pizza in west county. Maybe you didn't like the crust, but that is one of the best things about Deweys and the abundance of toppings.
Kurt Greenbaum August 03, 2011 at 09:32 PM
I agree with the results! I love East Coast Pizza.
Dawn A. Baggett August 04, 2011 at 04:39 AM
Sorry guys. Faraci's on Manchester is the best in West County. Thin crust with a bit of crunch; thick, rich tomato sauce and plenty of toppings. And the owner is truly Italian. Second place in West County goes to Fortel's on Old Ballas at Olive.
Natalia Motola August 05, 2011 at 07:29 PM
I did love Dewey's, I just like the crust better at East Coast Pizza, as well as the cheese.T
Gayle Grabish August 06, 2011 at 10:40 PM
I agree, Faracci's & Fortel's (I go to the one at Clayton & Kehr's Mill) are outstanding. Also, there is a new pizza restaurant in Ballwin, Pizza Pizza on Manchester Rd. They just had a write up in West News Magazine where it mentioned that they are now offering Pide (a Turkish-style pizza). Sounded good; will have to head back there soon to try this.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »